Over the past few weeks, a lot of people have been telling me that I need to see
Once because, you see, I'm a singer-songwriter and it's about singer-songwriters. I couldn't figure out why they did not also tell me to see
From Russia With Love on similar grounds, but I trust my friends and I tend to agree with
The Regular Guy and
The A.V. Club, so I rented
Once this weekend.
The story is certainly engaging and resonant, the songs are strong and the depiction of the songwriting and recording process (yes, there is definitely a "car test") was refreshing, if a bit treacly. But I couldn't help wondering how much having heard an hour of
Glen Hansard on Sound Opinions helped me along while watching the movie. Knowing what I did about the
history of the movie made it easier to get into the music and the story and not be distracted by the question of whether these were actors playing musicians or musicians playing actor (if you haven't seen the movie and it matters, try not following the link, OK?). It also helped knowing just enough about slavic languages to have a good guess at the key phrase in the second act, although I have to agree with the director's decision not to subtitle the Czech.
All of which, ultimately, tells me that
Once is a good movie but an even better DVD - the extra features and commentary help the movie make an intimate connection which is so critical to the songwriting and performing process. It is, in effect, the all-important
banter inbetween songs that brings audience and artist together. Certainly, there are plenty of artists who can walk on stage, say nothing at all, and perform for 90 minutes and make it worth the price of admission. Elvis Costello comes immediately to mind, though the last time I saw him at the Chicago Theater, he did take time between songs to respond to someone in the crowd by announcing "I will
not play [expletive]
Veronica." It was still a great show with great artistry and I'm glad I saw it. For my money, though, there's something about a show with a
storyteller that takes artistry to a new level. Some shows don't need it, and I don't think I'm going to start watching movies exclusively with the DVD commentary on from now on. But I will continue to hope that, if I've discovered a new musician whose songs I like on the radio or online, they'll tell stories about them when I go to see the show.
Once was helped by it quite a bit.
P.S.
Shotgun Stories was the best movie I saw in 2007 (that was released in 2007). The intensity of the third act was impressive, given the understated tones of the entire movie throughout.